Posted: Tue Jun 14, 2022 17:13 Post subject: WNDR3400v1 Strange 2.4GHZ Wifi
I have been having one of the weirdest WiFi issues ever with my WNDR3400V1. I tried searching the forum and Google and found nothing like it.
When I have the original Netgear Firmware on it, it works as expected for an N-Router. Like 30-50mbit for 2.4GHZ and 60-90Mmbit for 5GHZ for my 100mbit Internet.
Now, the issue with the Netgear Firmware is, after a day or so, the 2.4GHZ will just stop responding, especially for my smart home products. It then requires an entire reboot of the device.
So I put DD-WRT Mini 2022-06-10 on it, hoping that would help get rid of that frustrating bug.
Now the weird part is, even at default settings, the 2.4GHZ goes crazy with DD-WRT.
For some reason, my Onn 4K Android TV device will only pull like 1-3mbit out of it while my iOS device will put like 20-50 out of it. It seems the ping/jitter has increased also.
The 5GHZ seems mainly unaffected from what I can tell with original or DD-WRT firmware.
I have tried everything from lowering the TX power, disabling WMM, and many other settings. I tried the obvious like different channels, 20 vs 40MHZ, nothing.
Joined: 31 Jul 2021 Posts: 2146 Location: All over YOUR webs
Posted: Tue Jun 14, 2022 19:14 Post subject:
On the twidragon's note, I use a nifty opensource android app for the same job, works better for me since I dont have a desktop with wifi and my mobile is easier to walk around with
I have rebooted the Onn and it works perfectly on the 5GHZ again.
I did check various channels and moved them to where they are less crowded but it seems I can't find a completely free channel anywhere for 2.4GHZ.
I did get slightly more speed out of the 2.4GHZ on the Onn by rebooting it but strangely it still doesn't like it totally.
I am beginning to wonder if it's a weird issue with the Onn itself as on Reddit, people say they've had terrible luck at times with the 2.4GHZ on it and sometimes Bluetooth being near it can make it weird.
Strangely though, I don't know why the Onn doesn't really mind the original firmware's 2.4GHZ but doesn't really like DD-WRT's 2.4GHZ.
I really do think that something hardware related was going on.
Even with DD-WRT, the 2.4GHZ light and Ethernet would never stop blinking, as if traffic was being used constantly, even when all devices were calm.
I just gave up and slapped in my backup EA6500.
I could not be happier. Even on 2.4GHZ, which I guess would be technically Wifi-N is getting speed's I've never seen before from any N Router that I had.
I'm seeing 60-70mbit from 2.4GHZ.
I'm seeing at least 90mbit from 5GHZ. It probably would go higher but my Internet is only 100mbit and my QoS was triggering.
Joined: 31 Jul 2021 Posts: 2146 Location: All over YOUR webs
Posted: Wed Jun 15, 2022 19:12 Post subject:
Lights blinking means there is some broadcast going on, even when devices are idle or so you think, there is always something going on, you can monitor this within your network to confirm. Everytime you mention this Onn I cringe wondering what the heck it maybe transmitting without you knowing.
In any case lights blinking isnt an issue its just lights.
Now re: your problems with 2.4Ghz with the other router, have you stopped to think perhaps your wifi setup wasn't optimal? Obviously you did not.
Also you Onn whatever that is, still should get a firmware/OS upgrade, because sometimes these random android boxes just have crappy drivers and firmware's to begin with.
Joined: 16 Jun 2022 Posts: 16 Location: Dallas, TX
Posted: Fri Jun 17, 2022 23:08 Post subject:
Perhaps post all your settings for basic + advanced for the 2.4 GHz interface configuration? dd-wrt enables you to have precise control over your wifi settings but at the expense of you learning and experimenting with the settings.
For example, on mine I initially had issues with my 2x 5GHz bands overlapping on their channels, so one SSID would be visible to most clients, but other would only be visible to a select few, usually those within feet of the router.
And even then, performance (in terms of throughput) was poor on those networks.
Through research/experimentation I eventually found the basic + advanced configuration that worked well for me and achieved the performance I expected. Sometimes setting changes didn't take for me until I did a full reboot of the router during initial setup, especially as I was tinkering with all the knob/dials.
Vendor firmware already has all the settings dd-wrt exposes tuned to specific values. But with dd-wrt you have to learn how to control them yourself.
The above links provide recommended settings that deviate from the defaults. But also search the forums for your router to see if anyone has recommended values that differ.
Use this edit of the Basic Wireless Settings wiki. Most of the edits after that doesn't apply to Broadcom (driver specs). _________________ "The woods are lovely, dark and deep,
But I have promises to keep,
And miles to go before I sleep,
And miles to go before I sleep." - Robert Frost
"I am one of the noticeable ones - notice me" - Dale Frances McKenzie Bozzio
Joined: 31 Jul 2021 Posts: 2146 Location: All over YOUR webs
Posted: Sat Jun 18, 2022 10:26 Post subject:
redpenguin wrote:
I did try everything in that post about WiFi.
It did seem that even with DD-WRT on it, over time it would randomly stop accepting 2.4 clients.
You can easily setup a cron job to restart the radios or the interfaces rather at a time when network is mostly idle like overnight or at a similar time during the day. Depends how many hours going between the issues you noticed.
That's the fastest workaround. while on the other end especially Broadcom side where drivers are closed source, so fixing bugs is way harder since as I understand it their code is spaghetti. Blame Broadcom not DD-WRT, these days cant even blame Broadcom since they sold their Wireless division to someone else. I don't think the new owners are very opensource friendly either. I would venture a guess... If they have audited the drivers source code, "they" likely would be opening themselves to (my guess, cof cof, cant stress that enough, in case they come try sue me.) law suits from other vendors, were the source to be made public for everyone to see.
TBH on mine its solid and reliable also Broadcom. But OK to be fair, I flash 2 to 4 test builds a day (most days) so I cant compare with a setup that is likely upgraded once in a blue moon and has long uptimes.
Lat time I had a hiatus it was 2 months from late December 2021 to Early March 2022, my wifi was on 24/7 with a long uptime but I wasnt monitoring the devices 24/7 and I always use static IP assignments anyway.