Posted: Thu Feb 18, 2016 0:37 Post subject: Re: Made the plunge, but have problems
jsebean wrote:
vnvjeep wrote:
vnvjeep wrote:
jsebean wrote:
Doesn't sound like you did anything wrong as far as uploading is concerned. By any chance have you downloaded the wrong build for a different router version or did the build you download get corrupted? Try redownloading a build and uploading again.
I thought of that too, and made sure I got the right one. Downloaded it 2x. From here: (ftp://ftp.dd-wrt.com/betas/2016/02-15-2016-r29085/linksys-wrt1900ac/)
Same deal each time. Bah.
I guess these are some of the things I'm going to try... not really sure, but I'm wondering if my 2nd partition is intact? So let me know if there might be another thing I can do?
1.) I'm first going to do a reset, possibly a 30-30-30 reset, and try it again.
2.) I'm currently on stock v1.10, and will flash v1.8 on it to see if it makes it onto the 2nd partition. I'll try uploading it from v1.8.
3.) Manually switch to the 2nd partition (whatever is running on it at the time) with the power on/off trick x 3, and see if I can upload the .img file from the 2nd partition.
Any other ideas?
Whatever partition is running will overwrite the other. I don't see any need in uploading an old version of the WRT firmware but whatever floats your boat
As for your download... the discussion thread for the build you are trying shows others with v1's have no issues. I have seen some browsers cache corrupt versions of files. Perhaps try clearing your browsing data or try downloading it in a different browser?
For reference... if you can check the md5 of the build (See WinMD5) I have downloaded said build myself and this is the hash so you can check for corruption, just to rule that out:
Code:
factory-to-ddwrt.img for v1 BS build 02-15-2016-r29085
03c910b7ece7870f3dc9a82ed44b0eb3
So I finally got this working... I tried flashing the latest beta (that came out today), and had the same issue where it rebooted on itself 3x, ending up back on stock v1.10 each time. So, this is what I did:
1.) Flashed v1.08, and found that it was now on partition 2.
2.) Flashed the latest beta .img (29114 - 2/17/2016) from v1.08, and seemed to install just fine this time. It ended up going onto partition 1.
Anywho... all good. Now trying to figure out why wifi speeds are so dang slow. :/
I've been reading the forums for a few weeks now and I'm still on the fence in regards to flashing the WRT1900AC v2. I read through various topics and bought the WRT1900AC v1... read some more and took it back. Found the v2 today and purchased it... again I read up and even after this latest build (v3.0 --- 29085 --- 2016/02/15), there still seems to be issues. Am I missing something buried in these discussions? Do I roll with one of the recommend/stable builds or wait for a better build?
Location: Japan
ISP: 1Gbps Fiber optic
Router: Unopened WRT1900AC version2
VPN: Private Internet Access
Once flashed I'll read up on installing the VPN client, just added the info in case it effects anything. Thanks in advance.
Joined: 17 Feb 2010 Posts: 611 Location: Yorkshire (GOC)
Posted: Thu Feb 18, 2016 18:38 Post subject:
WeezyMoss wrote:
I've been reading the forums for a few weeks now and I'm still on the fence in regards to flashing the WRT1900AC v2. I read through various topics and bought the WRT1900AC v1... read some more and took it back. Found the v2 today and purchased it... again I read up and even after this latest build (v3.0 --- 29085 --- 2016/02/15), there still seems to be issues. Am I missing something buried in these discussions? Do I roll with one of the recommend/stable builds or wait for a better build?
Location: Japan
ISP: 1Gbps Fiber optic
Router: Unopened WRT1900AC version2
VPN: Private Internet Access
Once flashed I'll read up on installing the VPN client, just added the info in case it effects anything. Thanks in advance.
Yep you have just traded active cooling for a slightly faster CPU. Not a great decision IMHO !
Nothing wrong with the V2 and NAS performs better on it. Works fine for me.
Quote:
Yep you have just traded active cooling for a slightly faster CPU. Not a great decision IMHO !
I can now see why BrainSlayer said he was considering yanking out the temperature monitoring feature _________________ Want to get ahold of me? Contact me via one of the links here: http://jse.io/ or via discord at https://discord.gg/NmYX6enh
---
Current Router Setup:
OEM Satellite internet -- I'll likely get back to DD-WRT again when I get better internet
I never said there was anything wrong with the V2. I don't think it's superior to the V1, however. _________________ Routing:.......Asus RT-AX88U (Asuswrt-Merlin 384.14) Switching:....Netgear GS608_V3 & GS605_V4, TrendNet TEG-S82G & TEG-S50G
I never said there was anything wrong with the V2. I don't think it's superior to the V1, however.
Well that's subjective but who cares _________________ Want to get ahold of me? Contact me via one of the links here: http://jse.io/ or via discord at https://discord.gg/NmYX6enh
---
Current Router Setup:
OEM Satellite internet -- I'll likely get back to DD-WRT again when I get better internet
I never said there was anything wrong with the V2. I don't think it's superior to the V1, however.
Well that's subjective but who cares
Objectively, look at the number of people here who have zero problems with their V1 and DD-WRT. Then look at the number of people here who have V2/ACS and do have problems.
It's a more mature platform. _________________ Routing:.......Asus RT-AX88U (Asuswrt-Merlin 384.14) Switching:....Netgear GS608_V3 & GS605_V4, TrendNet TEG-S82G & TEG-S50G
Objectively, look at the number of people here who have zero problems with their V1 and DD-WRT. Then look at the number of people here who have V2/ACS and do have problems.
It's a more mature platform.
I don't know how you picked that up. Specifically since the main issues people have is with things like 5GHz, which is not version specific, latency on wifi issues, etc. Some people happen to have v1, some v2, it's just what they bought. Most didn't pick.
There is no difference between the two as far as "stability". It's not a contest. Just very slightly different models, one with a slightly faster CPU without a fan and one with a fan and slightly slower CPU. _________________ Want to get ahold of me? Contact me via one of the links here: http://jse.io/ or via discord at https://discord.gg/NmYX6enh
---
Current Router Setup:
OEM Satellite internet -- I'll likely get back to DD-WRT again when I get better internet
The core group of people here that post similar experiences to mine (I know some of them from other forums, BTW) have 2 things in common:
1. They don't use NAS or other "extra" features.
2. They have a V1.
I can tell you from other forums as well that the ACS/V2 tends to have more issues than the V1. _________________ Routing:.......Asus RT-AX88U (Asuswrt-Merlin 384.14) Switching:....Netgear GS608_V3 & GS605_V4, TrendNet TEG-S82G & TEG-S50G
Posted: Sat Feb 20, 2016 18:58 Post subject: Re: Made the plunge, but have problems
vnvjeep wrote:
jsebean wrote:
vnvjeep wrote:
vnvjeep wrote:
jsebean wrote:
Doesn't sound like you did anything wrong as far as uploading is concerned. By any chance have you downloaded the wrong build for a different router version or did the build you download get corrupted? Try redownloading a build and uploading again.
I thought of that too, and made sure I got the right one. Downloaded it 2x. From here: (ftp://ftp.dd-wrt.com/betas/2016/02-15-2016-r29085/linksys-wrt1900ac/)
Same deal each time. Bah.
I guess these are some of the things I'm going to try... not really sure, but I'm wondering if my 2nd partition is intact? So let me know if there might be another thing I can do?
1.) I'm first going to do a reset, possibly a 30-30-30 reset, and try it again.
2.) I'm currently on stock v1.10, and will flash v1.8 on it to see if it makes it onto the 2nd partition. I'll try uploading it from v1.8.
3.) Manually switch to the 2nd partition (whatever is running on it at the time) with the power on/off trick x 3, and see if I can upload the .img file from the 2nd partition.
Any other ideas?
Whatever partition is running will overwrite the other. I don't see any need in uploading an old version of the WRT firmware but whatever floats your boat
As for your download... the discussion thread for the build you are trying shows others with v1's have no issues. I have seen some browsers cache corrupt versions of files. Perhaps try clearing your browsing data or try downloading it in a different browser?
For reference... if you can check the md5 of the build (See WinMD5) I have downloaded said build myself and this is the hash so you can check for corruption, just to rule that out:
Code:
factory-to-ddwrt.img for v1 BS build 02-15-2016-r29085
03c910b7ece7870f3dc9a82ed44b0eb3
So I finally got this working... I tried flashing the latest beta (that came out today), and had the same issue where it rebooted on itself 3x, ending up back on stock v1.10 each time. So, this is what I did:
1.) Flashed v1.08, and found that it was now on partition 2.
2.) Flashed the latest beta .img (29114 - 2/17/2016) from v1.08, and seemed to install just fine this time. It ended up going onto partition 1.
Anywho... all good. Now trying to figure out why wifi speeds are so dang slow. :/
I am about to embark on flashing dd-wrt on my wrt1900AC v1 . I am running the stock firmware version 1.1.10.167514
Just in case I run into the same problem , where can I get the 1.08 firmware from Linksys? I tried looking at their downloads page and could only find the version 1.10
My plan is to download the Kong version from 2/15/16 img file. Flash using the excellent instructions from jsebean and then enjoy the new goodness of dd-wrt.
Just wanted to be prepared and have access to the 1.08 firmware in case I face the same problem as vnvjeep.
Joined: 10 Jan 2016 Posts: 62 Location: California, USA
Posted: Sat Feb 20, 2016 22:31 Post subject:
htismaqe wrote:
The core group of people here that post similar experiences to mine (I know some of them from other forums, BTW) have 2 things in common:
1. They don't use NAS or other "extra" features.
2. They have a V1.
I can tell you from other forums as well that the ACS/V2 tends to have more issues than the V1.
htismaqe,
I noticed the trend too with the posts here on this forum. The V1 routers seem to have less people complaining about issues. It may be that the open source wireless driver saw more dev time at Marvell on V1s, who knows. All I know is my experience with the V1 has had no performance issues like others have posted so far. All I have found is cosmetic web interface issues and configuration bugs in the web interface in dd-wrt and most have already been addressed by BS/Kong. _________________ Linksys WRT1900AC-V1 (BS 29048) • Motorola SB6141 • Netgear Gigabit Switches • 16 Wired/12 Wireless